Valteray is an independent financial comparison platform. We may earn a commission when you click through.
Student Loans Compared: Seven Rates, Seven Trade-offs
Listed rates range from 6.85% to 10.5%, but collateral, course eligibility and lender terms can change the real cost.
Quick Picks
Lowest listed rate: PNB Saraswati Education Loan and Bank of Baroda Baroda Gyan Education Loan, both shown at 6.85%.
Best mainstream rate match: Axis Bank Education Loan and SBI Student Loan Scheme, each listed at 6.9%.
Best for a borrower comparing private-bank access: ICICI Bank Education Loan at 8.5%; the rate is higher than the public-bank leaders, so eligibility and total fees need close checking.
Student-loan rates look close on paper: five of the seven listed products sit between 6.85% and 7.25%. That narrow spread can hide a meaningful difference over a long repayment period, especially once processing charges, collateral rules, margin requirements and interest during the study period enter the calculation.
The figures below come from the supplied listings and linked lender pages. They are starting or representative rates, not guaranteed offers. A bank may price the loan differently based on the institution, course, destination, co-applicant, security and credit profile.
Rates and terms shown are representative. Your actual rate depends on your credit profile and circumstances. This is not financial advice — always read the lender's terms before applying.
For primary verification, compare the SBI Student Loan Scheme, PNB education-loan information and ICICI Bank’s official education-loan page before submitting an application.
The Low-Rate Cluster: 6.85% to 6.9%
The cheapest listed rates differ by just 0.05 percentage points. That is too small to decide a loan by itself. A lower headline rate can lose its advantage if the lender requires more security, applies a larger margin or charges more during processing.
PNB Saraswati Education Loan
PNB has the lowest listed rate at 6.85%, tied with Bank of Baroda. The supplied page confirms an education-loan product but does not provide enough scraped detail to verify fees, collateral thresholds or repayment concessions, so the rate should be treated as a starting point rather than the full offer. Best for a student whose course and co-applicant already fit PNB’s documented eligibility rules and who is prepared to compare the sanction letter line by line.
Bank of Baroda Baroda Gyan Education Loan
Bank of Baroda matches PNB at 6.85%, making it one of the first quotes to request. The product is identified as Baroda Gyan Education Loan, but the supplied page extract does not expose enough detail on fees or security to call it cheaper in practice. Best for applicants who can compare two public-bank sanction letters and choose on collateral, margin and repayment terms rather than a 0.05-point rate gap.
Axis Bank Education Loan
Axis Bank’s listed rate is 6.9%, only 0.05 points above the two lowest entries. That difference is unlikely to matter as much as approval conditions, documentation and any processing charge. The supplied BankBazaar extract is thin, so applicants should verify the current Axis offer directly. Best for a borrower who wants a private-bank quote alongside public-bank comparisons and can qualify for the advertised rate.
SBI Student Loan Scheme
SBI also appears at 6.9%, putting it within the lowest-rate group rather than clearly below it. The official page is the right place to confirm current scheme rules, eligible courses, security requirements and repayment structure because the supplied extract mainly contains disclaimer text. Best for families who want a large-bank benchmark and are willing to compare the complete written terms against PNB and Bank of Baroda.
Here is the less obvious point: a 0.05-point advantage is not automatically worth changing banks for. On a long education loan, the repayment schedule, interest treatment during the moratorium and upfront charges can outweigh that tiny rate difference. Ask every lender for the total payable amount, not just the advertised percentage.
Canara sits just above this group at 7.25%. That is still close enough to merit a quote, especially if its approval route or security terms fit the family better.
When Eligibility and Access Matter More Than the Headline Rate
A rate above 7% is not automatically poor value if the loan is easier to process or fits the applicant’s institution and funding schedule. The available data is limited, so these products deserve a document-level comparison rather than a ranking based only on price.
Canara Bank Vidya Turant Education Loan
Canara Bank Vidya Turant is listed at 7.25%, 0.4 points above the lowest rate in this comparison. That premium may be acceptable if the applicant’s course, co-applicant and funding timeline align better with Canara, but the supplied extract does not verify speed despite the product name. Best for a student who needs a Canara quote and will confirm processing time instead of assuming the title guarantees fast approval.
ICICI Bank Education Loan
ICICI’s listed rate is 8.5%, materially above the 6.85% floor and 1.25 points above SBI and Axis. That makes the product harder to justify on price alone. Its official page provides a direct application route, but the supplied content does not establish fees, approval speed or collateral terms. Best for an applicant who values a private-bank application channel and has checked that the service or eligibility fit outweighs the higher rate.
HDFC Bank Education Loan
HDFC has the highest listed rate here at 10.5%, a full 3.65 points above the 6.85% low. That gap deserves serious scrutiny: on a large balance, it can add substantial interest over time even before fees are counted. The supplied page extract does not reveal a feature that offsets the price. Best for a borrower who has a specific HDFC eligibility reason and has obtained a written total-cost comparison from lower-rate lenders first.
HDFC is the contrarian pick in this set: the 10.5% listed rate makes it difficult to recommend as a first application. ICICI is cheaper, but still costs more on paper than every public-bank option listed here. That does not make either private-bank product unusable; it means the applicant should demand a clear explanation of the difference in eligibility, service, security or funding terms before accepting the quote.
Do not compare only monthly instalments. A longer tenure can make a higher-rate loan look affordable each month while increasing the total interest substantially. Use a loan calculator with the proposed amount, moratorium treatment, repayment start date and every disclosed fee.
Who Should Choose Which Loan?
Choose PNB or Bank of Baroda if the priority is the lowest listed rate and the family can satisfy the lender’s security and documentation requirements. Their 6.85% pricing leads this comparison, but the supplied data does not prove which one has lower fees.
Choose SBI if you want a major-bank benchmark at 6.9% and are prepared to verify the scheme’s current eligibility and collateral rules on the official page. It is the quote I would place beside PNB and Bank of Baroda before making a decision.
Choose Axis for a private-bank comparison at a rate close to SBI’s. It makes more sense for a borrower with strong documentation and a clear reason to prefer Axis than for someone chasing the absolute lowest number.
Choose Canara only after confirming the practical meaning of “Vidya Turant.” The 7.25% rate is still near the low end, but speed should be verified rather than assumed from the product name.
Choose ICICI if its application route or eligibility fits your situation and the bank’s written offer explains the 8.5% price. Approach HDFC cautiously: at 10.5%, it needs a specific justification and a full-cost comparison before application.
Smart loan choices start here, but the final decision belongs in the sanction letter, not the headline rate. For a deeper comparison of borrowing costs, amounts and fine print, read Student Loans Compared: APRs, Amounts and Fine Print.